fbpx

Accrual Claims Against a Deceased Estate: What Surviving Spouses Should Know

When a spouse dies, the surviving partner’s financial position depends heavily on how the marriage was structured in law.

For couples married out of community of property with the accrual system, South African law provides a specific mechanism that can significantly affect how much the surviving spouse ultimately receives, separate from anything left to them under a will. This is known as an accrual claim, and many surviving spouses are unaware it exists until an executor or attorney raises it during estate administration.

At Executor Law, we regularly guide surviving spouses through this process, since getting the calculation and timing right can make a meaningful difference to the final outcome. This guide explains what an accrual claim is, how it’s calculated, and how it fits into the broader estate administration process.

What Is the Accrual System?

South African matrimonial law recognises several marriage regimes, including in community of property, out of community of property without accrual, and out of community of property with accrual.

The accrual system, governed by the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, was designed to balance fairness with financial independence. Each spouse keeps their own separate estate during the marriage, but when the marriage ends, whether through death or divorce, the spouse whose estate grew by a smaller amount is entitled to share in the growth of the other spouse’s estate.

This means that while the couple’s assets remain legally separate throughout the marriage, the accrual system recognises that both spouses typically contribute, directly or indirectly, to the overall growth of the household’s wealth, and aims to prevent one spouse from being left significantly worse off simply because assets were registered in the other spouse’s name.

How Does an Accrual Claim Arise on Death?

When one spouse in an accrual marriage dies, the surviving spouse (or, in some cases, the deceased spouse’s estate, if the surviving spouse’s estate grew more) becomes entitled to lodge an accrual claim. This claim is calculated by comparing the growth of each spouse’s separate estate from the start of the marriage to the date of death.

Importantly, this accrual claim exists independently of whatever the deceased spouse’s will provides. Even if the will leaves the surviving spouse little or nothing, the accrual claim is a legal entitlement that must be settled before the rest of the estate is distributed to other beneficiaries. It is treated as a claim against the estate, similar in priority to a creditor’s claim, rather than as an inheritance.

How Is the Accrual Calculated?

The basic formula compares the net value of each spouse’s estate at the end of the marriage (in this case, the date of death) to the net value at the start of the marriage, adjusted for inflation using the Consumer Price Index.

Certain assets are excluded from this calculation by law, including inheritances, legacies, and donations received by either spouse during the marriage (unless the antenuptial contract specifically states otherwise), along with damages for non-patrimonial loss such as pain and suffering.

Once both estates’ growth figures are determined, the spouse whose estate accrued by the larger amount owes the other spouse (or their estate) half of the difference between the two accrual amounts. In practice, this often requires detailed financial records going back to the date of marriage, which is why couples married with accrual are strongly encouraged to keep clear records of their asset values at the commencement of the marriage.

How Does This Interact With Estate Administration?

Once an executor is appointed and begins administering the estate, the accrual claim needs to be identified and calculated early in the process, since it directly affects how much is available for distribution to heirs and beneficiaries. The executor must gather the necessary financial information for both spouses’ estates, often going back decades, to perform this calculation accurately.

This can meaningfully extend the time needed to finalise an estate, particularly where records are incomplete or where the surviving spouse and other beneficiaries do not agree on the figures involved. In some cases, professional valuations or forensic accounting input may be required to settle the calculation with confidence.

Once the accrual amount owing to the surviving spouse is confirmed, it is paid out of the estate before the residue is distributed according to the will or the rules of intestate succession. Only after the accrual claim has been settled can the executor proceed to finalise the liquidation and distribution account for the Master of the High Court.

Executor stamping estate documents to finalise an accrual claim in a deceased estate.

Common Points of Confusion

Surviving spouses often assume that being married with accrual automatically means a straightforward equal split of everything, which is not accurate. The accrual system only addresses the growth in each estate’s value over the course of the marriage, not an equal division of all assets outright. A spouse who entered the marriage with substantial pre-existing wealth that didn’t grow much over the years may be owed little or nothing under an accrual claim, even if the overall estate appears large.

There is also sometimes confusion between accrual claims and maintenance claims. These are separate legal mechanisms. An accrual claim relates specifically to the growth of each spouse’s estate under the matrimonial property regime, while a maintenance claim relates to ongoing financial support a dependant may be entitled to, regardless of the marriage regime involved.

Why Early Legal Guidance Matters

Because an accrual claim can significantly affect the final distribution of a deceased estate, and because the calculation itself can be complex and record dependent, surviving spouses are well advised to seek guidance as early as possible in the estate administration process. Waiting until the later stages of winding up the estate can lead to delays, disputes with other beneficiaries, or a rushed calculation that doesn’t accurately reflect the true position.

Getting Your Accrual Claim Right

Every marriage, and every estate, carries its own specific financial history, so the figures involved in an accrual claim can vary significantly from one case to the next. This article provides general guidance based on South African law and should not be treated as a substitute for advice tailored to your specific marriage and estate.

Executor Law assists surviving spouses and executors in correctly identifying, calculating, and settling accrual claims as part of the broader deceased estate administration process, ensuring the right amount is accounted for before any distribution takes place.

Speak to Executor Law about your accrual claim →


Frequently Asked Questions

What marriage regime allows for an accrual claim?

Only couples married out of community of property with the accrual system can lodge an accrual claim. Couples married in community of property share a joint estate automatically, while those married out of community of property without accrual have no claim to share in the growth of the other spouse’s estate.

Does an accrual claim override what’s written in a will?

Yes, in effect. An accrual claim is a legal entitlement that exists independently of the will and must be settled before the rest of the estate is distributed, regardless of what the will says about the surviving spouse’s inheritance.

What assets are excluded from the accrual calculation?

Inheritances, legacies, and donations received during the marriage are generally excluded, along with damages awarded for non-patrimonial loss such as pain and suffering, unless the antenuptial contract states otherwise.

Can an accrual claim delay the winding up of an estate?

Yes, particularly where financial records from the start of the marriage are incomplete or where the calculation is disputed. Gathering accurate figures can take time and sometimes requires professional valuation or accounting input.